19 Fall Bake Sale Ideas

Planning a bake sale this season? From pumpkin desserts and apple recipes to fall cookies and easy bars, these fall bake sale ideas are crowd-pleasers that sell fast.

Whether you’re looking for easy fall treats that save well when you make them ahead or simple desserts for a crowd to make a lot of servings for a bake sale, this list has plenty of inspiration. Think gooey bars, spiced cookies, apple pie-filled bakes, and pumpkin treats that everyone will want a piece of.

Let’s make some fall bake sale treats!

Pumpkin Scones

Pumpkin Scones are a perfect fall bake sale treat. They’re great for breakfast or when you’re craving a not-too-sweet dessert, plus they just look pretty on a bake sale table.

Crumbl Copycat Pumpkin Cookies

A caramel pumpkin crumbl copycat cookie on a plate iwth a bite taken out of it

I love these pumpkin cookies. They have a thick swirl of caramel frosting and are a homemade version of Crumbl Cookie pumpkin cookies. With the popularity of Crumbl plus those pumpkin fall flavors, they’re sure to be a hit at a fall bake sale.

Cranberry Gingerbread Cookies

thumbprint cookies on a tray - gingerbread cookies with cranberry sauce filling

These gingerbread cookies have a unique fall spin with their cranberry sauce filling. They’re well balances and look pretty, making them an easy sell at a bake sale.

Pumpkin Whoopie Pies

Pumpkin whoopie pies are the perfect fall bake sale treats. They’re so nostalgic and a pumpkin dessert, so really a win win.

Chocolate Covered Apple Pretzels

pretzels dipped in chocolate to look like red apples

How cute are these chocolate covered apple pretzels? They are easy to make but still look impressive. They’re a great one for a school bake sale.

Cinnamon Pecan Cream Cheese Muffins

Cinnamon Pecan Cream Cheese Muffins have cozy fall flavors with the cinnamon and pecan. The middle has a layer of cream cheese filling that keeps the muffins soft and moist. They’re great for a morning fall bake sale.

Cranberry Eggnog Truffles

cranberry pistachio eggnog truffles on a wood plate with ingredients in the background

These cranberry pistachio eggnog truffles capture all the cozy flavors of fall in a single bite. Plus, they’re no-bake and super easy to make.

Mini Apple Hand Pies

Mini Apple Hand Pies are a quintessential bake sale item. They’re all the goodness of an apple pie, packaged nicely in a handheld treat. It makes them easy to sell in a bake sale setting.

Mixed Berry Sweet Rolls

Overhead view of the fully frosted skillet of sweet rolls, garnished with fresh strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries for a colorful finish

Mixed Berry Sweet Rolls are perfect for bake sales in any season. People love them and they’re more unique than a classic cinnamon roll.

Apple Crisp Bars

Any bar dessert is a good choice for a bake sale because you can make lots of portions more easily. These apple crisp bars have great fall flavors so they’re an obvious choice for a fall bake sale.

Butterfinger Bars

Stack of Butterfinger Cookie Bars in a plate

Staying with the dessert bars, these butterfinger cookie bars are awesome and can fit a Halloween candy vibe at a bake sale.

Oatmeal Cream Pie Bars

One last bar to round out our dessert bars, these oatmeal cream pie bars will be a favorite at your next bake sale. They’re another nostalgic dessert but this time in bar form, making them easier to make and portion for a sale.

Halloween Chocolate Covered Oreos

A plate full of decorated Halloween Oreos with vibrant sprinkles, eyeballs, and various fun Halloween toppings

I like these Halloween chocolate covered oreos because they’re bright, fun and a good bake sale treat for kids. They also aren’t so overtly Halloween-y that they won’t work for a bake sale that doesn’t celebrate Halloween.

Apple Cider Cookies

These apple cider cookies are soft, full of warm spices, and finished with a light apple cider glaze. They’re simple to make because you use apple cider instead of prepping apples, but are packed with that classic spiced apple flavor.

Pumpkin Streusel Cookies

These pumpkin streusel cookies are soft, spiced, and topped with a buttery crumble and sweet brown sugar glaze. They’ve got all the cozy flavors of fall wrapped up in one simple pumpkin cookie.

Apple Texas Sheet Cake

sliced caramel apple sheet cake in a plate

Apple Texas Sheet Cake is another amazing bake sale idea because you can make a lot of cake slices easily. It’s the perfect dessert for a crowd and the apple flavors fit perfectly with a fall theme.

Apple Galette

Easier than a pie, Apple Galette looks rustic and pretty with all the same great apple flavors. It slices up and serves well at a bake sale too since it’s less of a wet filling than a pie.

No Bake Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies

Stack of pumpkin pudding no bake cookies in a wooden chopping board

These pumpkin oatmeal cookies are great for bake sales when you need something easy. They come together so fast and they also sell well at bake sales because people love a touch of healthiness from the oatmeal.

Carrot Cake Muffins

Carrot Cake Muffins have those spiced flavors you associate with fall, and are popular at an autumn bake sale. Muffins are a nice addition because they sell well and are easy to package at a bake sale than slices of carrot cake.